Human depression: a new approach in quantitative psychiatry

Abstract

The biomolecular approach to major depression disorder is explained by the different steps that involve cell membrane viscosity, Gsα protein and tubulin. For the first time it is hypothesised that a biomolecular pathway exists, moving from cell membrane viscosity through Gsα protein and Tubulin, which can condition the conscious state and is measurable by electroencephalogram study of the brain's γ wave synchrony.

Introduction

The need for a deep, radical turning point in the world of psychiatry is rapidly growing. Present diagnostic methods cannot continue to be considered acceptable because they are almost completely based on the psychiatrist's opinion, which does not have an objective diagnostic technology and thus has a very high error rate.

A debate is essential between the advocates of traditional diagnostic and therapeutic methods and advocates of emerging methods resulting from new discoveries. Major depressive disorder and other related and non-related psychiatric conditions are still characterised and defined by descriptive and non-biological criteria, but it is hoped that we can adequately characterise this and other psychiatric disorders with the addition of new quantitative approaches.

Human depression in the interpretation of an artificial neural network

Following the theory that a biomolecular involvement of the cell could be an expression of a psychiatric disorder, we have tried to understand and explain this phenomenon.

The intention was to study the platelet fatty acids composition in normal and depressed subjects [1], because of their similarity to neurons [2–10].

Membrane platelet fatty acids of subjects with a clinical diagnosis of major depression versus apparently normal subjects were assessed. The complexity of membrane dynamics has also suggested study by means of non-linear advanced analytical tools would be appropriate. In particular, it seemed more appropriate to use artificial neural networks: the self-organising map (SOM) Kohonen network [11–13]. This particular algorithm allows viewing of the result graphically, building a two-dimensional map that places the subjects in a continuous, not necessarily dichotomised way.

The values for fatty acids in the two populations were entered into the SOM, mixing normal and pathological subjects and hiding the information relating to their pathological condition. The SOM was then used to map the two populations using three specific fatty acids: palmitic acid (PA), linoleic acid (LA) and arachidonic acid (AA), which represent the majority of total membrane fatty acids, recognising as similar those belonging to the same population and then separating the normal cases from the pathological cases [1]. All the artificial neural networks (ANNs) tested gave essentially the same result. However, the SOM gave superior information by allowing the results to be described in a two-dimensional plane with potentially informative border areas. The central property of the SOM is that it forms a non-linear projection of a high-dimensional data manifold on a regular, low-dimensional (usually 2D) grid.

This experiment was performed outside of evidence-based medicine (EBM) rules. The direct task of finding biomarkers according to the EBM rules requires the elimination of selection bias, and in psychiatric illness the leads to the selection of a population that is often clinically unrealistic. The results are shown in Figure 1a, b.

Figure 1

Distribution of the human subjects (normal and depressive) over the self-organising map (SOM) (a), and SOM areas (b). (a) The distribution of the 144 subjects studied, 60 apparently healthy (green) and 84 diagnosed as depressed (red) effected by the SOM allowed us to identify 4 areas: 2 specific ones (exclusively normal and exclusively pathological) and 2 mixed with different concentrations of pathological subjects and apparently normal subjects of the sample. The red subjects in the two intermediate areas (yellow and orange) have been interpreted as having a misleading diagnosis of major depression, as described in the literature [14]. (b) SOM areas. Green = normal, red = depressive, yellow = high density of normal subjects, orange = high density of pathological subjects.

The SOM has shown considerable correlation to the clinical diagnosis of major depression, and indeed, revealed the existence of differences within the same diagnosis. The literature shows that a diagnosis of major depression is very often misleading, and can be changed to a diagnosis of bipolar disorder [14].

Using the following equation (Equation 1), which relates each fatty acid percentage with the melting point and the molecular weight, we obtained a result that led us to understand that platelet membranes had different degrees of viscosity and/or unsaturation (B2 index).

Where A _i = percentage of i-th fatty acid, mp = melting point, mw = molecular weight, mw _i = molecular weight of i-th fatty acid, mp _i = melting point of i-th fatty acid, and i:

• 1 = palmitic acid, C 16:0

• 2 = linoleic acid, C 18:2

• 3 = arachidonic acid, C 20:4

The result clearly showed that the platelet membranes of depressive subjects were characterised by a much higher degree of fatty acid unsaturation than normal subjects.

According to Donati et al. [15] rapid changes in membrane lipid composition or in the cytoskeleton could modify neuronal signalling. As this could have implications for a new understanding of some aspects of psychiatric disorders, a private meeting was organised in Bologna (Faculty of Veterinary Medicine) and in Treviso, University, October 2008) with some expert scientists in the field (Kary Mullis and Stuart Hameroff).

Three essential points constituted the crucial elements of the discussion at the meeting: (1) the viscosity of the platelet and neuronal membrane; (2) the protein Gsα; (3) the relationship between tubulin and consciousness.

With regard to the first point, Cocchi and Tonello observed that the platelet membrane was substantially differentiated from a chemical point of view with regard to the indexes of saturation between depressed and normal populations [1].

On the second point, the protein Gsα modifies its structure according to the degree of viscosity of the neuronal membrane, as seen in patients who commit suicide for psychiatric reasons in comparison to deaths from other causes [15].

With regard to the third point, Tubulin, because of its connection to Gsα and its position in the cellular cytoskeleton, determines those changes that have been assessed with quantum computation under conditions of wakefulness in comparison to the condition of anaesthesia [16].

Biomolecular depression hypothesis

A very suggestive hypothesis was built, as summarised in Figure 2.

Figure 2

Description of the biomolecular steps possibly involved in depressive disorder.

Figure 2 describes the molecular depression hypothesis formed according to the experimental findings of Cocchi et al. [1], Donati et al. [15], Hameroff and Penrose [16, 17] and Hameroff [17]. Because of the possible similarity in behaviour of platelets and neurons, membrane viscosity may therefore modify the Gsα protein status. The Gsα protein is connected with tubulin. Tubulin, depending on local membrane lipid phase concentration, may serve as a positive or negative regulator of phosphatidylinositol bisphosphate (PIP2) hydrolysis, as G proteins do. Tubulin is known to form high-affinity complexes with certain G proteins. The formation of such complexes allows tubulin to activate Gα protein, which, in turn, can activate protein kinase C (PKC), and fosters a system whereby elements of the cytoskeleton can influence G-protein signalling. PKC activation (Figure 3) is preceded by a number of steps, originating from the binding of an extracellular ligand that activates G-protein on the cytosolic side of the plasma membrane [18].

Figure 3

Description of protein kinase C (PKC) activation.

The G-protein, using guanosine triphosphate (GTP) as an energy source, then activates PKC via the PIP2 intermediate, the diacylglycerol/inositol triphosphate (DAG/IP3) complex [15]. The schematic biomolecular mechanism of the Gsα protein is described in Figure 4.

Figure 4

Ligand reaches the receptor and guanosine-5'-triphosphate (GTP) reaches the protein. Cell membrane proteins coupled to cell surface receptors bind to GTP upon stimulation of the receptor by an extracellular signalling molecule (as a hormone or neurotransmitter) to form an active complex that mediates an intracellular event (for example, activation of adenylate cyclase).

The Gα subunit is activated and starts a cAMP signalling cascade, as shown in Figure 5.

Figure 5

cAMP signalling pathway.

The international scientific literature has reported abnormalities in the cAMP signalling cascade of the human brain in suicidal and depressive subjects for over two decades [19–25].

According to Donati et al. [15] there is a further possible condition: the position of Gα (Gsα in particular) within the lipid raft microdomain. Lipid rafts are specialised structures on the plasma membrane that have an altered lipid composition as well as links to the cytoskeleton (Figure 6). They are local lipid microdomains that float in the liquid-disordered lipid bilayer of cell membranes. The effect of lipid rafts on neurotransmitter signalling has also been implicated in neurological and psychiatric diseases [26].

Figure 6

Schematic representation of a lipid raft microdomain.

Raft localisation of Gsα in human peripheral tissue (possibly platelets, see [15]) may thus serve as a biomarker for depression. Several studies using human platelets suggest that adenylyl cyclase may, in fact, serve as a biological marker for depression [27–34].

The membrane fatty acid-Gsα hypothesis

It is known that G proteins could be targeted to raft domains by several mechanisms. The most plausible mechanism is that Gα subunits are subject to palmitoylation. Palmitoylation is a process of covalent attachment of palmitic acid to cysteine residues of membrane proteins.

Palmitic acid is one of the three fatty acids (together with arachidonic acid and linoleic acid) used by SOM as marker of depression [1].

Is the critical composition of the membrane platelet fatty acids an indirect measure of the G protein status? (see Figure 7.)

Figure 7

Schematic description of the possible link between the two research projects on platelet fatty acids and Gsα protein [1, 14].

Rapid changes in membrane lipid composition or in the cytoskeleton might modify neuronal signalling. Hameroff hypothesised that through this mechanism it is possible to modify the consciousness state [16, 17]. According to Hameroff [16, 17] the best measurable correlate of consciousness is a γ synchrony electroencephalogram (γ waves are a pattern of brain waves, with a frequency between 25 to 100 Hz, prototypical at 40 Hz), which indeed rapidly moves and redistributes throughout the brain. γ Synchrony derives not from neurocomputation, but from groups of neuronal dendrites (and glia) transiently fused by electrical synapses called gap junctions, more or less sideways to the flow of neurocomputation. The process could be mediated by tubulin and its correlates i.e. membrane viscosity and Gsα protein (see Figure 2).

Recent studies reported a model of the disconnection hypothesis of schizophrenia through the demonstration of abnormal stimulus induced γ phase synchrony [35].

The idea discussed by the authors with Hameroff and Mullis that platelets could represent the peripheral markers of the depressive disorder and that platelets are 'brain ambassadors', has become a more and more realistic proposal [36].

Conclusions

On the basis of the above-cited research it is possible to try to understand and quantify some of the biological aspects that characterise depression in order to enable an objective diagnosis to be made through simple and inexpensive blood tests. Such tests, and the biomolecular pathways upon which they are based, would also represent early indicators of therapeutic effectiveness. These possibilities represent a genuine revolution not only in psychiatry but more generally in the worlds of neuroscience and medicine, as Mullis and Hameroff have highlighted in a recent interview on the subject [37, 38].

Observed changes in the serotonergic and microtubular systems in the hippocampus following restraint stress confirm the structural [39, 40] and biochemical [41] vulnerability of this area to stressful conditions. Cytoskeletal changes represent a potential new pathway that may increase our understanding of psychiatric disorders. The question of whether or not changes in 5-hydroxytryptamine (5-HT)-serotonin levels are related to changes in the expression of tubulin needs to be assessed by future studies [42]. Already in 1980 it has been shown a relationship between serotonin receptors and lipid membrane fluidity: as the membrane lipids become more viscous, the specific binding of serotonin increases steadily. Signal transduction, either through activation of adenylate cyclase by the ligand-receptor complex or by microaggregation of ligand-receptor complexes, is associated with lateral movements of components of the membrane which are determined, at least partially, by lipid fluidity [43]. Since it is well known that Gsα protein and tubulin have a connexion [44] it seemed to us reasonable to raise the question of a possible link to consciousness according to Hameroff-Penrose Orch theory [16, 17]. The results will have practical use and be of great interest in more than one scientific field of application e.g, in the study of new drugs for psychiatric disorders and in the diagnostic evaluation of depressive disorders.